Tailoring Pants for Square
The Pants build system announced a 1.0 release.
Written by Eric Ayers.
This week, the Pants project announced a 1.0 release of the open source Pants Build System. The 1.0 release of Pants indicates that the tool is ready for more widespread adoption.
Square is a proud contributor to Pants. Developers at Square have been using and contributing to Pants since 2014 to develop our Java services. When we first joined the project, we found a tool that required lots of customization and insider knowledge to install and operate. Today the tool has a streamlined installation process, extensive documentation, a clean extensible design, a vibrant community and a history of stable weekly releases.
With Pants we get:
Reliable, reproducible builds from the current view of the code repository
A streamlined development workflow
Easy IDE setup
Strong integration with third party artifact repositories
Consistent results when switching branches
A distributed build cache that can be shared with CI builders and developer laptops
Lots of built-in tooling to help us analyze our large build graph
The ability to define fine grained dependencies between code modules
An extensible tool that can grow with our needs
We build and release services from HEAD of master. Our Java codebase is housed almost entirely in a single repo consisting of over 900 projects and 45,000 source files. In this style of development, we prefer keeping all code at HEAD consistent using global refactoring and rigorous automated testing instead of maintaining strict API backwards compatibility and long deprecation cycles within the codebase.
We also have a strong commitment to using open source libraries. We extensively rely on artifacts published through the Maven Central Repository. When we upgrade a library, we can do so in one place and update the code dependencies for all services.
With such a large codebase, it becomes impractical to load the entire repo into the IDE. At Square, we primarily use IntelliJ IDEA to develop code. We use Pants to configure and launch it. Probably the most valuable feature for day to day development is simply having the ability to quickly bring up any portion of the repo in IntelliJ. With a single command, Pants configures IntelliJ to edit a module and all of its dependencies defined in the repo.
Making it easy to configure any project in the IDE means that developers can easily contribute to any project in the codebase. Being able to easily switch between branches encourages developers to collaborate. Now it is convenient to check out each other’s work locally when performing code reviews. It is easier to confine change requests to small, manageable chunks and switch between them while waiting on code reviews to complete.
We came to the Pants project looking for a tool to help solve problems in our build environment. Previously, we used Apache Maven to compile and package binaries. Maven is a powerful and popular tool with a modular design that makes it easy to extend with excellent support from third party tools and libraries. We had a significant investment in Maven, including many custom plugins for running code generation and supporting a distributed cache for artifacts in our continuous integration (CI) build system.
Using Maven with our “build everything from HEAD” policy strains the Maven model. Maven is designed to support editing a few modules at a time while relying on binary artifacts for most dependencies. To support building the entire repo from HEAD, we set every Maven module in the repo to a SNAPSHOT version.
Using Maven in this way works, but has drawbacks. Running a recursive compile of all dependent modules incurs a lot of overhead. We had wrapper scripts to help us try to be productive in this environment, say to run just run code generation or only run a subset of tests. Still, developers would get into trouble in some situations, often having to deal with inconsistencies between stale binary artifacts and the source on disk. For example, after using mvn install, pulling in new changes from the repo or switching back to an older branch could leave them compiling against stale code. When developers routinely question the integrity of their development environment, they waste a lot of time cleaning and rebuilding the codebase.
Our first priority was to allow developers to quickly configure their workspace in the IDE. Next, we migrated to using Pants as the tool to test and deploy artifacts in our CI builder. As of this writing, we have replaced all of our use of Maven in this repo using Pants, including:
Developing on developer workstations and laptops
Compiling and testing code in our continuous integration environments
Publishing artifacts to a Maven style repository
Integrating with third party tools like findbugs and kloc
Replacing all of our uses of Maven was not easy. We were able to do this by generating the Pants configuration using the Maven pom.xml files as a source of truth. During an interim phase we supported both tools. Through collaboration with the Pants open source community, we were able to modify Pants through hundreds of open source contributions.
Pants comes out of the box ready to edit, compile, test, and package code. Beyond that, we were able to leverage Pants’ extensible module based system. A current favorite is a small custom task to deploy directly to staging environments over our internal deployment system. Along the way, other custom modules run custom code generators, gather meta information about our build process for our security infrastructure, and package the output of annotation processors into yaml files for our deployment system. Today we have about two dozen internal Pants plugins that do all those things, plus additional tools to audit our codebase, integrate with our CI system, and customize our IDE support.
At Square, Pants has helped us realize the promised benefits of monorepo style development at scale. Making sure the development process is consistent and reliable increases our developer velocity. Being able to quickly and reliably edit, compile, and test allows developers to concentrate on reviewing and writing code, not struggling with configuring tools. We believe that Pants is ready for more widespread adoption and encourage you to give it a try. Eric Ayers - Profile *Hi Omari, I read your post and just wanted to express my support. I don't feel like you are responsible for this or…*medium.com